Product management systems characterized by high entropy, as evidenced by large percentages of firefighting activities, face increased risks of operational failure or diminished effectiveness. A 2024 Product Focus survey revealed that product managers spend a significant portion of their time on unplanned, reactive tasks, which can be detrimental to overall productivity and strategic planning. According to the survey, 45% of a product manager's time is dedicated to firefighting activities. In practical terms, this translates to:
Firefighting: Approximately 2 weeks per month
Planned activities: Approximately 2 weeks per month
This nearly equal split between reactive and proactive work is indicative of a high entropy product management system. It presents a challenging scenario for product managers and their organizations.
"If you spend all your time fighting fires, you may miss critical opportunities to build your business. You’ll be all reaction and no action." - Reid Hoffman
Types of Firefighting Activities That Reduce Effective Product Management
Product managers often find themselves engaged in various unplanned activities that detract from their core responsibilities. These firefighting tasks, while sometimes necessary, can significantly impact the efficiency and effectiveness of product management efforts. Here are the main types of such activities:
Addressing Urgent Customer Issues and Requests
Handling critical customer problems or urgent feature requests from key clients disrupts planned work but is crucial for maintaining customer satisfaction.
Accommodating development of product features for multiple prospect opportunities that may not align with established strategies and roadmaps.
Resolving Cross-Functional Conflicts and Communication Gaps
Mediating conflicts between different teams (e.g., sales, engineering, marketing) and ensuring proper communication to keep projects on track.
Involving numerous impromptu meetings and discussions.
Fixing Product Defects and Technical Issues
Coordinating with engineering to prioritize and quickly resolve major bugs or technical problems, which can derail planned feature development work.
Managing Scope Changes and Shifting Priorities
Accommodating frequent product change requests stemming from loose strategic company direction.
Rapidly adjusting plans and reprioritizing work due to sudden shifts in business priorities or urgent requests from leadership, requiring constant juggling of the roadmap.
Handling Escalations from Sales and Support Teams
Addressing urgent escalations about deals at risk or major support issues, diagnosing root causes, and developing solutions.
Dedicating significant time to sales opportunities outside the communicated Ideal Customer Profile (ICP) and targeted market segments.
Participating in numerous unplanned meetings with teams not directly involved in the feature development pipeline.
Resolving senior leadership concerns that have escalated without following established interdepartmental resolution pathways.
Creating Company and Product Strategies to Fill Gaps
Developing product management strategies in the absence of clear company goals and strategies (Value Creation Plans) or when established they are lacking in quality. This requires the product management team create substitutions or proxies for the company strategies.
Table: Firefighting Activities and Impacts
Signatures of Prospering, Low Entropy Product Management Systems
Low Entropy Product Management Systems are characterized by a structured and efficient approach to product development and strategy.
Strong Company Strategy
A well-defined, articulated, and documented company strategy, such as a Value Creation Plan, serves as the foundation for all product-related decisions. This overarching strategy provides clear direction and aligns all departments towards common goals. It ensures that product initiatives contribute directly to the organization's vision and long-term objectives and have alignment with the other departments initiatives.
The McKinsey Three Horizons Framework effectively assists senior leadership in developing, planning, and documenting a Value Creation Plan or a comprehensive company-wide strategic plan. This framework provides a structured approach to managing both current operations and future growth opportunities, enabling leaders to balance their focus on immediate business needs while also exploring long-term innovations. By utilizing this model, organizations can ensure that they are not only maximizing the value of their existing core businesses but also strategically positioning themselves for sustainable growth in the future.
Robust Product Management Strategy
Building upon the company strategy, a strong product management strategy translates high-level objectives into actionable plans for product development. This strategy outlines specific product goals, target markets, and competitive positioning. It serves as a bridge between corporate vision and tactical execution.
One particularly effective tool for developing and communicating product strategy is a competitor matrix enhanced with Harvey balls. This visual representation offers several advantages, including a comprehensive overview that illustrates the product's strengths and weaknesses in relation to competitors. It also highlights targeted improvements for upcoming releases, facilitating future planning. The use of a competitor matrix fosters alignment among stakeholders, making discussions and decision-making among team members and executives more efficient.
Comprehensive Product Roadmaps
A detailed product roadmap visualizes the product strategy and communicates the plan for implementation. This roadmap outlines key milestones, features, and releases over time, providing stakeholders with a clear view of the product's evolution. It serves as a coordination tool, helping teams prioritize efforts and allocate resources effectively.
Product roadmap communication is essential for aligning stakeholders and guiding development efforts. When employing a strategic framework like McKinsey's Three Horizons, three complementary roadmap tools can effectively convey planned work, milestones, and progress.
Now/Next/Later Roadmap (Horizon 1)
The first tool is the Now/Next/Later roadmap, which focuses on immediate priorities and near-term objectives over a 12-month period. This roadmap provides a clear view of current development efforts (Now), upcoming features and enhancements in the pipeline (Next), and potential future initiatives being considered (Later). This format is predicated on assumed confidence levels with the highest being Now and the lowest being Later initiatives. It offers flexibility while maintaining a structured approach to short-term planning, allowing for easy reprioritization as market conditions or customer needs evolve.
Strategic Initiative Roadmap (Horizon 2)
The second tool is the Strategic Initiative Roadmap, which covers a 12-36 month timeline and outlines key strategic initiatives beyond product development. This includes market research projects, partnership explorations, potential acquisition evaluations, and technology infrastructure upgrades. This roadmap helps stakeholders understand the broader organizational efforts that will shape the product's medium-term future.
Product Vision Roadmap (Horizon 3)
Finally, the Product Vision Roadmap serves as a high-level overview of the long-term vision for the product and its ecosystem. It typically includes anticipated market trends and disruptions, evolving customer needs and behaviors, and potential pivots or expansions for the company. This roadmap acts as a north star, guiding decision-making and ensuring alignment between short-term actions and long-term goals. By utilizing these three roadmap tools in conjunction, product managers can effectively communicate plans across all time horizons, fostering better understanding and buy-in from stakeholders throughout the organization.
Culture of Strategic Discipline
A low entropy system thrives on a culture that values disciplined focus. While feature prioritization, resource allocation, and transparency undoubtedly contribute to organizational discipline, they do not significantly reduce firefighting as much as an unwavering adherence to strategic discipline. This approach minimizes wasted effort, reduces confusion, and maximizes the likelihood of delivering successful products that align with both company goals and market needs.
Light at the End of the Tunnel
There is indeed light at the end of the tunnel for product management teams facing challenges. By implementing a combination of quick wins and focusing on more strategic initiatives, product management can evolve into a successful, low-entropy machine characterized by minimal firefighting and maximum efficiency.
Quick Wins
Prioritization: Teams should concentrate on high-impact initiatives that align with currently known strategic goals. This focus ensures that efforts are, at least, directed towards the most valuable outcomes.
Transparency: Clear and consistent communication ensures all stakeholders understand and support the product vision and roadmap. This alignment fosters collaboration and reduces misunderstandings.
Strategic Initiatives (but Heavier Lifts)
Strategic Company Plans: For private equity-owned companies, this may be referred to as a Value Creation Plan. As the Head of Product (HoP), collaborate with the senior leadership team to develop, document, and frequently communicate a comprehensive strategic company plan. This plan serves as a north star for all product decisions and initiatives. Influence your CXOs to undertake this effort as one of the top priorities to set the company on a pathway for success.
Product Management Strategies: As the HoP, implement robust product management strategies or improve existing ones if necessary. These strategies should be well-documented and communicated frequently to ensure alignment across the organization.
By implementing these quick wins and strategic initiatives, product management teams can create a more streamlined, efficient, and value-driven process. This approach not only reduces the need for constant firefighting but also positions the product team as a strategic driver of company success.
Need help creating, implementing, or optimizing your product management machinery, contact Froogel Product Manager. We can help you.
Share this post